Debbie's Reviews > The Many Lives of Mama Love: A Memoir of Lying, Stealing, Writing, and Healing

The Many Lives of Mama Love by Lara Love Hardin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8665845
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: netgalley, favorite-memoirs, 2023-runners-up

A soccer mom turned addict

I liked this memoir about a rich soccer mom who has a secret opioid addiction, steals money from friends, and ends up in jail. The story flows just like a good novel. There’s a lot of dialogue, and I always flinch a bit when a writer uses dialogue and quotation marks a lot in a memoir—how could she possibly remember such detailed conversations from her past? The dialogue made the story richer and more dramatic, but it made the memoir lose a little credibility, too. It reminds me that I can’t believe everything I read. Conversations could not possibly have gone down exactly like she said.

I was pulled into this memoir from page 1. Before you know it, she’s in jail. Her four-year-old son is sent to live with relatives (though not blood relatives), but she’s freaked, of course. It looked like her prison sentence would be long and she would lose custody. I can’t believe it (because I know a lot about addiction), but I felt judgy! (I hang my head in shock and embarrassment!) I couldn’t stand that she had risked depriving a kid of his mom for what looked to be his whole life—and she had three other boys, too, who lived with their dad. What was she thinking to let herself get addicted? Ha, yes, I know that’s not how addiction works—of course she didn’t choose to take a risk that might end in her losing her sons, but still, I was miffed. I’m a mama bear when I come across a really bad mom; I want to protect the youngins.

But I forgave her as the story progressed. She became a hero of sorts in jail, helping other women write appeals and letters. Her husband was a doozy, and I liked how well she outlined their complex relationship. I don’t want to spoil the story, so I won’t tell you anything more. I’ll only say that she continued to be a hero in my eyes. She was so strong and persistent and patient.

A couple of things bugged me—things she left out. For instance, she didn’t talk about how rough it was to detox in jail. I would have thought she’d go into that because of how hard and major kicking an addiction is. Also, she doesn’t explain how she afforded things on the outside. I’m guessing she chose to leave these topics out, but I wanted to know about them.

The main gist of the story is about how messed up the jail story is in America, how once you get in the system, it’s nearly impossible to get out. Much food for thought. She gets her point across without being preachy, which I appreciate.

The story is riveting and so well told. The author is a writer by trade, and she has the chops for sure. I was sucked into her life completely and was rooting for her all the way. But—and this is weird—it’s been a few weeks since I finished reading this book, and I don’t have that glow-y feeling that happens when I think back on a good book. So I guess all that means is that it doesn’t fall into the Amazing Book category. But after my initial, short judgy period, I just loved reading the book, and that’s what counts.

Thanks to NetGalley for the advance copy.

Expected publication date: August 1, 2023
68 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Many Lives of Mama Love.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 2, 2023 – Shelved
May 2, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
May 2, 2023 – Shelved as: netgalley
May 22, 2023 – Started Reading
May 31, 2023 – Finished Reading
June 18, 2023 – Shelved as: favorite-memoirs
June 18, 2023 – Shelved as: 2023-runners-up

Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh How is this so far, Debbie?


Debbie I liked it! 4 stars. Review a-comin'! Are you going to read it? It's one of those books that had my full attention and at the time was sort of riveting, but I can't remember a lot about it.


message 3: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh Oh, I know those, Debbie. Isn’t that the strangest thing? I was just thinking about two titles where all I remember was the enjoyment!


message 4: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh I think I’ll try it, Debbie, but I can’t say when…


message 5: by Bianca (away) (last edited Jun 19, 2023 05:22AM) (new)

Bianca (away) Great review, Debbie. Hey, the US is great at something, you have the most incarcerated people per capita!!! John Oliver and Jon Steward had shows focused on the f..ed up prison system in the States. Scary stuff.


message 6: by JanB (new)

JanB Great review Debbie. I struggle a bit with memoirs, either I find them full of humble bragging and/or I struggle to believe what I’m reading.


Lisa (NY) Great review - I have the ARC for this one so plan to read it soon!


Canadian Jen I like the sound of this one too, Debbie. Thanks for the enticing review - will be adding!


message 9: by Julie (new)

Julie G Debbie,
I started nodding over here, when I read: I always flinch a bit when a writer uses dialogue and quotation marks a lot in a memoir—how could she possibly remember such detailed conversations from her past?

Yes, soul sister, I have the same issue. I'm a person who pays close attention to what is being said around me, and I try to visualize more memorable comments, so that I may recall them later, and still. . . I doubt that most of us can do any better than paraphrase later, and we probably get that wrong, too.

I have a close relative who landed himself in jail a couple of times, and the thing that struck me the most about his jail time was how hard it was for him to get out. If you're white, and you've got a lawyer, you stand a better chance than others. . . but even that's complicated. Add some brown skin to the equation, and/or limited resources, and you're in trouble. Our jail system is a mess and most people aren't aware, or feel they have nothing to contribute to the problem, so it remains one of our biggest businesses that is subjected to very little scrutiny or restrictions. If this author shed any light on this, then she's doing us all a favor.


Debbie Jennifer wrote: "I think I’ll try it, Debbie, but I can’t say when…"

Jennifer—hope you get the chance to read it. I’m always looking for compadres!


Debbie Bianca wrote: "Great review, Debbie. Hey, the US is great at something, you have the most incarcerated people per capita!!! John Oliver and Jon Steward had shows focused on the f..ed up prison system in the State..."

Thanks, Bianca. I knew we’d shine somewhere, lol. The system is sooooo bad! John Oliver is my hero.


Debbie JanB wrote: "Great review Debbie. I struggle a bit with memoirs, either I find them full of humble bragging and/or I struggle to believe what I’m reading."

Thanks, Jan. Yeah, the humble bragging gets to me, too. And so many are about addicts that turn it around—gets old. Plus the quotes really did make it lose some of its believability. Still, this was interesting, mostly because it read like a good novel.


Debbie Lisa (NY) wrote: "Great review - I have the ARC for this one so plan to read it soon!"


Thanks, Lisa. Look forward to your thoughts on this one!


Debbie Jen CAN wrote: "I like the sound of this one too, Debbie. Thanks for the enticing review - will be adding!"

You’re welcome, Jen. I think you’ll like this one. The writer is so articulate and knows how to tell her story. Plus she’s likable (after the beginning, that is).


Brandice Great review, Debbie! I enjoy memoirs but often wonder about the elements left out in some instances… I appreciate when people acknowledge their privileges, which unfortunately aren’t always an accessible resource to everyone.


message 16: by Christy (new) - added it

Christy fictional_traits This sounds really interesting - great review. Addiction really knows no bounds.


Debbie Julie wrote: "Debbie,
I started nodding over here, when I read: I always flinch a bit when a writer uses dialogue and quotation marks a lot in a memoir—how could she possibly remember such detailed conversations..."


Julie—hey soul sister, I’m so glad the dialogue in memoirs bothers someone else! Not only is it impossible to remember things verbatim, the memories morph over time and aren’t to be trusted anyway. Anyone could turn a benign memory into a whopper without even realizing it.

I think this story would remind you of your friend. Because of her addiction and the fact that she stole from friends, her finances weren’t good, but she did have help from family—a clear and huge advantage over poor people. Still, like your friend, she did not have it easy, and she was able to shed light on how messed up the system is.


Debbie Brandice wrote: "Great review, Debbie! I enjoy memoirs but often wonder about the elements left out in some instances… I appreciate when people acknowledge their privileges, which unfortunately aren’t always an acc..."

Thanks, Brandice! She definitely came from a privileged background and was white, so she had it better than most. Still, the system was really hard on her. It didn’t seem like her background or color mattered in many ways, so we got to see how nearly impossible it is for anyone with her record to stay out of jail.


Sarah Obsesses over Books & Cookies I really liked this too! As far as dialogue goes, I think she was always a writer and kept journals most of her life which helps.


message 20: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never come across in a normal day, that's for certain! And I'm totally with you on the incredulous use of quotation marks!😲 Come on!! How on Earth would ANYONE, EVER remember even ONE single sentence, word for word!??? I just can't happen, so please dispense with the quotation marks and put it in italics or preface it with "all quotes are approximations" or something along those lines.🙄 Anyway, wonderful review, Debbie!!! (P.S. I hope you're well - it's been ages since we chatted! Take good care, my friend!🌷)


Debbie Christy H wrote: "This sounds really interesting - great review. Addiction really knows no bounds."

Thanks, Christy. I know—hard to watch people go down the tubes. Addiction is a beast. It’s always great when we see them climb back up.


Debbie Sarah Obsesses over Books & Cookies wrote: "I really liked this too! As far as dialogue goes, I think she was always a writer and kept journals most of her life which helps."

Sarah—glad you liked it, too! It’s helpful to think she had journals to pull from, thanks! That makes me feel better about it. I still think she could have ditched the quote marks. I would have preferred it if she said somewhere that dialogue was paraphrased.


Debbie Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never come across in a normal day, that's for certain! And I'm ..."

Thanks so much, Jodi! You always write such nice comments! It’s fun to know that the quotation marks would bug you, too! You have such a passionate reaction—I love it! Like I said in an earlier comment, our memories morph what happens in the past anyway, so there’s no guarantee that the quoted text is anything like what actually happened. Our memory makes things up, lol! I like your suggestion that a memoir writer say that the quotes are approximations. That would make me feel a lot better about it! It sure has been a while since we’ve chatted, I know! For some reason I haven’t been on GR as often this past month. Weird! I don’t know why! Anyway, hope you’re doing well, too! And reading some gems!


Margaret M - (too far behind to catch up although trying to spend more time on GR) Glad this was really good if not amazing. Wonderful review though Debbie 💖


message 25: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never come across in a normal day, that's for cert..."

Ah, Debbie, I've missed you!! I'm doing fine - reading lots of great books! You too, I hope!🌺


Debbie Margaret M wrote: "Glad this was really good if not amazing. Wonderful review though Debbie 💖"

Thanks so much, Margaret!


Debbie Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never come across in a normal day, ..."

I’ve missed you, too! Any 5 stars I need to know about?


message 28: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never come across in a..."

I've read several good ones lately! Just now I'm finishing up The Kingdom of Sand which is an excellent story but scary because it's so close to my own sad life, except that he's 1) gay, and 2) a man. But other than that... 😂


Debbie Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is something I'd never c..."

I just had to add this! Thanks for the tip!


message 30: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, which is somethin..."

Don't think you'll like it, Debbie. It's pretty depressing - probably not the kind of book you'd like. I read it hoping there'd be a "light at the end of the tunnel" kind of message in it, but at 85% it sadly doesn't seem to have one.😕


Debbie Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unusual book, wh..."

I don’t mind depressing, but I trust you when you say you don’t think I’ll like it. I’ll put it on the waaaaaay-later to-read pile!


message 32: by Jodi (new)

Jodi Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie wrote: "Jodi wrote: "Debbie, what a FANTASTIC, very enlightening review!!! You did a tremendous job of outlining this unu..."

👍


message 33: by Cheri (new)

Cheri This is one I've wondered about, Debbie, but need to spend more time working on my house before I can add any more books! So annoying, having to be an adult! Hopefully, my library will get a copy!


Debbie Cheri wrote: "This is one I've wondered about, Debbie, but need to spend more time working on my house before I can add any more books! So annoying, having to be an adult! Hopefully, my library will get a copy!"

Oh, I’m so sorry your house is taking you away from your beloved books! I’m sure that kills you! Is your house almost done? I thought you finished it last year. It’s probably a never-ending story!


From the Trenches Book Reviews Interesting thought on dialogue within memoirs; I hadn't thought of that.


message 36: by Karen (new)

Karen Terrific review, Debbie!


back to top