Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Prisoners of Peace #1

The Scorpion Rules

Rate this book
The world is at peace, said the Utterances. And really, if the odd princess has a hard day, is that too much to ask?

Greta is a duchess and crown princess—and a hostage to peace. This is how the game is played: if you want to rule, you must give one of your children as a hostage. Go to war and your hostage dies.

Greta will be free if she can survive until her eighteenth birthday. Until then she lives in the Precepture school with the daughters and sons of the world’s leaders. Like them, she is taught to obey the machines that control their lives. Like them, she is prepared to die with dignity, if she must. But everything changes when a new hostage arrives. Elián is a boy who refuses to play by the rules, a boy who defies everything Greta has ever been taught. And he opens Greta’s eyes to the brutality of the system they live under—and to her own power.

As Greta and Elián watch their nations tip closer to war, Greta becomes a target in a new kind of game. A game that will end up killing them both—unless she can find a way to break all the rules.

384 pages, Hardcover

First published September 22, 2015

About the author

Erin Bow

10 books774 followers
TEN THINGS ABOUT ME:

1. I'm a physicist turned poet turned YA novelist.
2. I am world-famous in Canada, which is kind of like being world-famous in real life.
3. I write books for young readers and people like me who didn't grow up. All my books will either will make you either cry on the bus or snort milk out your nose. I am dangerous to your dignity and should be stopped.
4. I needed WHERE THE RED FERN GROWS to have a happy ending, so I wrote a middle-grade book called STAND ON THE SKY
5. I needed a book with a Spock-like hero who was also a queer girl, so I wrote THE SCORPION RULES, and its sequel THE SWAN RIDERS.
6. I think cats can actually talk, but don't find us worthy, hence PLAIN KATE.
7. I hate horror, so I wrote a horror: SORROW'S KNOT,
7. I think Hufflepuff is the best house, Xander was the best Scoobie, Five was the best Doctor, and Spock was the best everything.
8. I am married to another novelist, and we can actually pay our bills. Our daughters want to be scientists.
10. My bookshelves will always be full.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,273 (18%)
4 stars
2,139 (31%)
3 stars
1,923 (28%)
2 stars
997 (14%)
1 star
528 (7%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,559 reviews
Profile Image for Emily May.
2,070 reviews313k followers
August 9, 2015
I picture Erin Bow smiling evilly as she wrote this book. I'm smiling now just thinking about the trap - disguised as the safe and old - that this book lures you into.

Because you know exactly what this is, right? You've read the description and you think you know what’s coming, don't you? A future world where an evil tyrant has taken over and enforced a set of crazy rules. A future world through the eyes of a female narrator who becomes irrevocably changed when a new boy comes into her life. You know this story.

Except this isn't the story you think you know. The Scorpion Rules is a clever, subversive addition to the dystopian genre. It takes the tropes we've all come to expect and it gives them the middle finger. It walks out into a genre where it's almost impossible to be shocked anymore and somehow constantly throws up surprises.

In this world, an artificial intelligence called Talis has taken over. Talis maintains peace by taking a hostage from every world leader - their heirs, known as "Children of Peace". If any government declares war, their child dies. These children are kept in a Talis-controlled centre and taught history and politics. Every day they wonder if their parents will have given in and gone to war. Every day they wonder if they're going to die.

But here's the thing. This book's "evil villain" is not a one-dimensional, mindlessly-cruel ruler. Talis is charming, witty and likable. We might not agree with everything he does, but since when did everyone agree with everything a governing body does? He has essentially taken over the U.N. and acts in its place. He holds children hostage and prevents even the poorest nations from acting out against the system. And yet, he has established world peace.

He's a fascinating character and it's easy to draw parallels between him and real-world leaders who make difficult, unpopular decisions for the good of their country.

And that new boy - Elián - disrupts the faux peace, but he is not the love interest in this novel. No, that would be Princess Xie. Though the book has very little romance, anyway.

Fans of simplistic world-building, fuelled-by-action books like Divergent might struggle with this. It's a complex, sophisticated piece of science-fiction and occasionally becomes a little info-heavy. But I found it so refreshing to see something this original and thought-provoking come to the dystopian genre. I enjoyed it immensely.

Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube | Pinterest
October 26, 2015
DNF at 75% because I'm so bored. No stars if I could. I'm so confused. And I just don't care.
A sonic boom.
It crashed into us like a slap to the ear. The stuck goat shouted. From the trees all around, loose apples pattered down. Grego bolted for the edge of the grove, leaving Atta alone with the ladder.
We all wanted to go with him, of course, but—
“Wait! The goat!” I called.
My classmates stopped and turned and looked at me. On their faces, varying degrees of annoyance, resignation, and respect sorted themselves into agreement, obedience. This is what it is like, in my experience, to speak as royalty. Even to other royalty.
“Our duty is with the goat,” I said.
The summary of the book makes it sound pretty great. The reality about this book is that it's about a bunch of kids living their life in a nonsensical and supremely confusion faux-dystopian world who have been sheltered their entire life with the knowledge that they are "hostages." A new stranger comes into their midst to be rebellious and get punished by the hostages' keepers and to tell them that THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY SEEM. Gasp. Shock. Horror. Awe. Such a thing has never happened before in dystopian fiction.



And there's a love triangle. And goats. Do you like goats? Do you really, really like goats? There's a lot of them. There are hundreds of mentions of goats in this book. Honestly, the goats are probably the most exciting thing in this book because nothing happens in this book at all.

Seriously. The kids talk to each other. They have their lessons. They're slightly rebellious. They get punished. They take care of goats. They gather fruits and vegetables. The end.
But the fun had gone out of things. A few shocks, distributed at random; the knowledge that we were watched; the fact that we had been raised better (or if not better, at least differently)—these overcame us. The Children of Peace could not easily be silly, and our silliness fell apart.

The evening found us bruised and quiet, spread out in groups or pairs on the spattered grass, eating our former ammunition—chunks of watermelon and muskmelon warmed by the bronze sun. Even this was unlike us—unstructured, unrationed eating, outdoors. But we could not waste so much food. We scattered up and down the garden terraces; we lay in the goat-cropped grass and were happy.
Yeah. That's what happens for the majority of the book! Exciting! There are 7 of them and I can hardly tell them apart. There is no character to any of them. No life. No soul.

You know who else is soulless? The main character, Greta. That's bound to spell doom for any book. It's just so fucking boring. I've read some reviews that rave about Talis. I don't understand it. Talis is hardly a character.

The conspiracy and the world building is so fucking confusing. I can hardly keep track of anything. It's both too simplistic and too complex, if that makes any sense. The shitstorm that happened to create this shithole of the setting in this book is just plain dumb and wouldn't hold water. No pun intended.
It started when the ice caps melted. We saw it coming, and we were braced for the long catastrophe, but in the end it came unbelievably fast. All of a sudden there were whole populations under water.


Because that's the best explanation EVER of how robots took over the world. And the world building. My lord. It's so awful. So there are a bunch of countries at war and each kingdom offers their kid as hostage and somehow there's a big bad robot who saved everything? Huh? And this country is allied to that country and this place is at war with that and...
The Cumberland Alliance emerged from a regional shakeup among the losing parties. Like many nations it was defined by water: in this case, the drainage of the Ohio River basin. It stretched south to Nashville and north to Cleveland, with a capital at Indianapolis and a military-industrial center at Pittsburgh.
I don't even care what happens. I don't even care that I can flip to the end to find out the conclusion. Bye.
Profile Image for Elle (ellexamines).
1,103 reviews18.9k followers
April 14, 2019
“Did you know, the man who invented the atomic bomb once said that keeping peace through deterrence was like keeping two scorpions in one bottle? You can picture that, right? They know they can't sting without getting stung. They can't kill without getting killed. And you'd think that would stop them." He gave the book another boot, and it flipped closed with a snick. "But it doesn't." He looked up and his eyes were the color of Cherenkov radiation, the color of an orbital weapon. "You've got a bit of nerve, little scorpion. All I did was invent the bottle.”

I think what truly stands out about this book is, to put it simply, how it goes around hitting dystopia tropes in the face. It's such a subtle subversion of everything I've come to expect from this genre.

♔ God, just... the use of tropes. The hot dude who changes things? He's not the love interest. The sudden disruption of life? Uhhhhh - no, it's pretty much a slow burn, actually. The rebellious hero? Definitely not the main character. Even if you dislike this book, you have to admit that Bow does a fabulous job subtly subverting tropes. This isn't just another tropey ya dystopia; it's something far more.

♚ This world is arguably more of a utopia than our world, which is exactly makes it so incredible. A slightly evil / slightly awesome AI controls the entire world and has prevented all war. Sure, it leads to a couple of deaths here and there, but ultimately there are far fewer deaths than there were during wartime. What I truly love is how this book doesn't have a clear good guy / bad guy distinction. Bow plays around with different viewpoints and moral ambiguity in an interesting way.

♔ Character work on point!! Greta is well-developed and likeable. So are all the side characters, especially Elian and Xie. Erin Bow also does a great job building relationships– Xie and Greta made me feel All The Things, and Elian and Greta's dynamic is interesting and multidimensional too. There's not really a love triangle, but Bow creates such an interesting relationship web.

♚ And to top it all off, there's the morally ambiguous and totally awesome villain. Talis is one of the most well-developed villains I have ever read, with believable motives and an interesting take on morality to back them up. You can genuinely see where he's coming from, while also seeing where the main characters are coming from. Bow portrays this dynamic so brilliantly.

Yes, this book is quite slow. And you know what? I did not even notice. It is a purposeful slowness, a purposeful build. There's tension in every moment. And the prose flows really well. I understand that the slowness could bug some, and that some are going to really despise this, but I really urge everyone to give this book a try and read to the end - it just keeps getting better.

VERDICT: Despite the incredibly polarizing reviews, I honestly can't tell you to read this enough. While there's of course the chance you might hate it - and you know what, I won't judge if you do - there's also a good chance it will be a new favorite that stays with you forever. And honestly, isn't that worth the risk?

Blog | Goodreads | Twitter | Youtube
Profile Image for Angela.
856 reviews1,489 followers
June 4, 2018
Dnf 65%.

If you like goats you'll like this book...



However I am not one of those people who like goats soooooooooooooooooo this wasn't for me.
Profile Image for Alienor ✘ French Frowner ✘.
870 reviews4,103 followers
February 15, 2021


4/4.5 stars. Welcome to my Unpopular Opinion Review of the month! (alright, I'm writing "unpopular opinion" reviews more often than that, BUT let's be honest, usually it's the other way around). What this means is : if you hated The Scorpion Rules, you might find me too lenient. Hello you! If you loved The Scorpion Rules, you might be happy to hear that no, you're not alone. Hello you! If you haven't read The Scorpion Rules, what are you waiting for? Hurry up and come back to tell me which category you fall into!

"Thus my heart began to turn against the only truth I'd ever known."



"Borders strained, checkpoints broke, and of course people started shooting, because that what passes for problem-solving among humans. See, guys, this is why you can't have nice things."

This is part of the prologue and I already knew that I would love it at this point.

So. Guys. I've read a lot that there wasn't any plot... and I'm going to politely disagree. Nothing happens is such a subjective thing, when you think about it. For me there's a difference between a lack of big events and a lack of progression. There IS a progression and nothing was irrelevant in my opinion. Of course, most of the first half deals with the Children of Peace's everyday life and that life is weird. I mean, there are goats and harvests and a lot of zucchini? (you might be worried at this point - DON'T)

The truth is, I can see why people would complain about this but I thought that it was incredibly well done. What annoys me in dystopian is : they're unrealistic (random couple saves the world for some reason), more often than not they're devoid of any world building (if you don't count "standard tyrant took over the world because he's evil" and... I don't, sorry but it's not a WORLD-BUILDING, it's A SIMPLISTIC SUMMARY OF WHAT HAPPENS EVERY DAY)

In The Scorpion Rules, it makes sense. THIS IS LIFE. THEIR LIFE. Of course it's relevant! Not to mention that it made for the BEST built-up. This book was crazy and NASTY (There's TORTURE) and also super weird BUT I loved every second of it. It took my breath away - and I didn't need big explosions to do so (even if they were fun hehe). It may have gone forward quietly, but it never lost its tension.

(this is the moment when my dear friends who hated it shake their head while murmuring "but the goats!")

(and it will probably be the only time I'll get to write this in a review but in my opinion, the goats were necessary to get the sense of what their world became. Oh my God, I love goats.)



1) I loved Elian almost instantly, and I'm not even ashamed. Because you know what? Even though I know that he's supposed to incarnate The Bad Boy New To School ™, by no means can he be restricted to this stereotype. HE IS MORE : fleshed out and brave and a coward and he doesn't know when to shut the fuck up even when mechanical spiders are scrawling all over him and electrocuting him (ow!). He's also loyal and charming and LOST. POOR BABY.

2) TALIS!!!! Give me a book in which I can LOVE the villain and you'll get a win almost every time. Think Deadpool on crack (I know, it's mind-blowing)(except, Talis actually, I don't know, wins sometimes?) Seriously guys, I was cracking up at the prologue without even knowing that the narrator would be a character (and at this point, my understanding of the world was nearly inexistent). The ruler of the world, who thinks that blowing up cities is fair game, whom we should hate, shows such a likeable personality, so damn sarcastic and funny, that we CANNOT hate him. Not for one second we cannot. Give him some slack! He's only acting for the greater good... I think?

3) Sure, Greta wasn't the most interesting character to read about, given that she was brainwashed into being a dull, nerd princess, BUT I completely bought her character, and that's saying something. Dull she was at first, yet I loved seeing her opening her fucking eyes and standing up for her friends. YOU GO GIRL.



Oh, how that (mostly unimportant aspect) was hated! First thing first : you need to know that the romance didn't affect more than 15 pages out of the whole book. I'd say that it's not enough to spoil the entire book if you don't like it, BUT sometimes one sentence can make me rage SO I won't be this person and disrespect that.

This said, here's what I think : Well, I think that our knowledge of the tropes make us reject anything that comes close to a love triangle and in my opinion it's pretty... frightening to see that we're so damn used to them that we analyze novels through their lens without even realizing it.

Look : There's this boy whose arrival is disruptive for the plot, so of course we expect him to be a love interest. What I mean is that in our head, we tick the love interest box. Is there something in the book, at this point, that actually implies it? Fuck no, but we don't need it, we just know it. Then when he's not a love interest - or, rather, when the situation reveals to be more complicated than that - we yell love triangle because really what else could it be?! Well it's not. No, in my opinion it's not. Yes, the MC kisses two different characters, but I don't have in me to restrain this situation to a love triangle as we generally understand it, that is to say some dumb girl who's hesitating through 3 books between Love Interest #1 (the Golden Boy) and Love Interest #2 (the Bad Boy), and whose whole behavior and decisions revolve around that fucking choice.

Try complex relationships instead. Friendship. Empathy.

See, I was talking to my dear Chelsea about it, and I told her this : since WHEN do I need for a character to be a love interest to love him? SINCE WHEN? Well, since every fucking character in every fucking YA book taught me that their personality would be ruined if they weren't love interest because THEY WOULD NOT MATTER. I can count on the fingers of one hand the number of characters I love in YA who aren't any kind of love interest, and for me it shows that there is a problem with YA. I used to ADORE characters who aren't romancey at all. Thank you Erin Bow for reminding me that.

My friend Laura said that she didn't so much see a love triangle but a fullness of love. I'm stealing that line. What love indeed. Who needs labels? I don't.

Can I just say something? I didn't feel an ounce of romantic chemistry between Greta and Xie. Sorry, OKAY? I just didn't. I wish I had, but what you gonna do. Oh, well. There's barely any romance anyway. FRIENDSHIP is what matters, NOT BEING BLOWED-UP is what matters, so I'd say that it's not a really important flaw in my book.

► Honestly? Such a good surprise, I cannot wait to see where the story goes.

For more of my reviews, please visit:

____________

4.5 stars, probably. I don't understand all the goat-hate in the reviews. I mean -
















WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH GOATS ??!!???!!!!???

Goats are awesome! The Scorpion Rules, if not perfect (this is me being truthful : there are flaws, okay? Loved it still), was awesome. THE DEADPOOL-LIKE VILLAIN WAS AWESOME (I TOTALLY WANT TO BUY HIS BOOK AND QUOTE IT ENDLESSLY). The farmer who goes bowling and gets electrocuted a LOT - ELIAN! - was awesome. It was crazy and NASTY and also super weird BUT YAY! Awesome!

RTC (I swear I won't use the word awesome anymore) (but I've been known for lying SO)
Profile Image for Tatiana.
1,461 reviews11.4k followers
March 28, 2016
I hate to disappoint Emily again, but I have to side with that half of the early reviews of The Scorpion Rules that uses words "flat" and "boring" a lot.

Erin Bow is a fine writer, but I guess she needs to eat too. Reading this novel was like reading something written to a certain request - a request to create another "bestseller" with a high concept and wide appeal. There was no life, excitement or surprise in the story, just one familiar trope after another. It started with a bit of Hunger Games (tortured children used as a political leverage, two teens pitted against each other who have a "thing" going on, the fatalistic mood of inevitable death – you know what I am talking about, right?), then it morphed into Mockingjay with its own version of Plutarch and Coin and its own media games... This whole thing was just so, so tired...

There were some tidbits of interest or note - some ideas about AI and philosophy, bisexual love triangle, diversity (you see, even more boxes checked?). Oh yes, and goats.

But as a whole I thought the novel was incredibly boring and trite. It didn't make a lot of sense to me, and I definitely didn't connect with any characters.

Sorry, Emily :(
Profile Image for Natalie Monroe.
606 reviews3,747 followers
September 21, 2015
1.5 stars

"You sound exactly like a textbook, do you know that?" he said. "It's amazing."


Took the words right out of my mouth. It's amazing The Scorpion Rules has managed to take an high-concept dystopian plot and mutilate it into bland, soulless mush. There's no spirit in this book. No soul, no spark.



It started awesome. Talis, the UN ambassador who ceased war in the Before, was narrating and the guy is charismatic as hell. He's snarky, morally dubious, and basically everything I want in an MC.

"All of a sudden there were whole populations under water. Which meant that whole populations moved. Borders strained, checkpoints broke, and of course people started shooting, because that’s what passes for problem-solving among humans. See, guys, this is why you can’t have nice things.


Then Self-Sacrificing Greta pokes her selfless nose in. It's so dull in her head. She speaks really formally, which I guess isn't her fault since she's royalty and a Child of Peace (hostage to ensure a country's good behavior), but it's also not my fault that I can't stand it.

Her actions are scarcely better. She follows the rules like a good girl and performs her duty as martyr when the time comes. Can you get any more Jesus? Give me your selfish heroines. Give me those who cackle evilly, who plot, who cheat, who fight and scratch.

Fuck it, just give me Talis. I promise I'll be good to him.



There are a lot of complex themes and moral issues presented with the subtlety of a shovel to the face. It's trying too hard. Reading The Scorpion Rules is like reading Victorian literature and God knows I do enough of that in college. I want to kick back, relax, let my brain unspool with complex themes and moral issues disguised as fun, readable literature. Because that's the sign of an awesome book. Make your readers think without them realizing they're thinking.



ARC provided by Netgalley. Quotes taken from an uncorrected galley proof and may be subject to change.
Profile Image for Chelsea Humphrey.
1,487 reviews82k followers
March 24, 2017
Oh gosh. Hm. Well, I'm not sure what to say, other than I don't think I'm enough of a hard core goat enthusiast to appreciate this book. In all seriousness, I think my main problem was a lack of connection to the characters which resulted in my zoning out and being a little bored. I did bump it up to 2 stars because it became more interesting in the end with a twist I didn't see coming. I'll have to think on this one some more and dream of baby goats and bigger goats and goats being wiped down with hormone creams tonight. Full review to come #allofthegoats
Profile Image for Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽.
1,880 reviews23k followers
September 24, 2015
Review originally posted at www.fantasyliterature.com:
Sit down, kiddies. Let me tell you a story. Once upon a time, humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.

Well, I say “my job.” I sort of took it upon myself. Expanded my portfolio a bit. I guess that surprised people. I don’t know how it surprised people — I mean, if they’d been paying the slightest bit of attention they’d have known that AIs have this built-in tendency to take over the world. Did we learn nothing from The Terminator, people?
So begins Erin Bow’s new young adult dystopian novel, The Scorpion Rules, with Talis, the snarky but cold-hearted artificial intelligence overlord of the earth, explaining how humanity got itself into its current bind. The earth’s ice caps melted, which led to massive population migrations and water and food shortages, and from there to global series of regional wars, disease and famine that led to a seventy-five percent reduction in earth’s population.

Then Talis took over, taking control of networked weapons systems, particularly those in orbit, and blowing up cities until countries obeyed his orders to stop shooting each other. But blowing up cities was not a feasible long-term solution to ending war. “Make it personal.” Talis instituted a rule that all rulers and leaders of the world’s countries had to have a child under age 18 live in an isolated enclave called a Precepture, run by robots and AIs, as a hostage to their country’s good behavior. If a country becomes involved in a war against another country — even if it was not the aggressor – the child’s life is forfeit. They are the so-called “Children of Peace.”

Four hundred years later, sixteen year old Greta Gustafson Stuart is crown princess of the Pan Polar Confederacy and a seventh generation hostage. She lives in a Precepture in Saskatchewan with a group of other hostage children, living in subsistence conditions despite their AI and robot teachers and guards. Other than the most mild disobedience (which includes sneaking off at night to have sex with each other), resistance has been trained out of Greta and the other children and teens at the Precepture.

Then one day a new hostage shows up who refuses to accept the status quo. Elián can’t win the battle against robot guards that shock and torture him when he says the wrong thing — “Hi. I’m Spartacus, and I’m here to lead you in a slave revolt” being just one of those things that get him an excruciatingly painful shock — especially when he finds that the rest of his group, the other older teens, are punished as well for his rebellious missteps. Not surprisingly, Elián makes plans to escape.

At this point, you might be forgiven for thinking this novel is fairly predictable: another dystopian teenagers in peril novel, another hair-raising escape, another love story between attractive teenage protagonists. I was certain I knew where the plot was heading. And I was completely wrong.

Erin Bow takes her readers in some genre-bending directions, particularly considering that this is a young adult novel. So major points for creativity, but readers should be aware that these unexpected developments do not necessarily make for pleasant reading, although it is compelling. There are detailed scenes of torture and cruelty, violence and death. Add to that a few F-bombs and some sexual content, both gay (or maybe bi?) and straight, though non-explicit, and this is a novel that I recommend only for mature older teens and adults.

With that caveat, I do consider The Scorpion Rules worth reading if you enjoy dystopian fiction and don’t mind if the ride gets rough. The writing is powerful and poignant, especially as Greta sees her options narrowing and her fate closing in.
In Halifax I am duchess and crown princess. When I come here the prairie sky opens up over me. I fold the crown princess away like linens into lavender, and I am Greta again… The last time I was in Halifax, my mother did not mention a war. But she did not invite me to privy council either, as she usually does. And on the last day of my visit she herself brushed the thousand strokes through my hair. She wasn’t crying, but she was….

Surely she would warn me. Surely she would not let me be surprised.
The characters in The Scorpion Rules are unique and diverse; hostages are gathered from all over the globe. Moreover, they are unique and fully realized, including the secondary characters. Thandi from Africa is touchy and prideful, but is protective of the group and the best person at judging how far the rules can be pushed. Talis, who controls the world, seemed at first improbably sarcastic and taunting for an artificial intelligence, but as the story unfolds and Talis’ background and history are disclosed, these qualities and other human-like characteristics in Talis are fully explained. Bow does an excellent job of fitting the pieces of the story together in a way that makes sense.

The Scorpion Rules is the first book in the Prisoners of Peace series. Although I’m somewhat hesitant about continuing with the series because of some of the disturbing content, I have to admit I’m quite interested in what becomes of Greta and her friends.

Free advance copy received from NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Thanks!
Profile Image for Alyssa.
1,069 reviews851 followers
August 20, 2015
***Review posted on The Eater of Books! blog***

The Scorpion Rules by Erin Bow
Publisher: Margaret K. McElderry Books
Publication Date: September 22, 2015
Rating: 1 star
Source: ARC sent by the publisher

Summary (from Goodreads):

A world battered by climate shift and war turns to an ancient method of keeping peace: the exchange of hostages. The Children of Peace - sons and daughters of kings and presidents and generals - are raised together in small, isolated schools called Prefectures. There, they learn history and political theory, and are taught to gracefully accept what may well be their fate: to die if their countries declare war.

Greta Gustafsen Stuart, Duchess of Halifax and Crown Princess of the Pan-Polar Confederation, is the pride of the North American Prefecture. Learned and disciplined, Greta is proud of her role in keeping the global peace — even though, with her country controlling two-thirds of the world’s most war-worthy resource — water — she has little chance of reaching adulthood alive.

Enter Elián Palnik, the Prefecture’s newest hostage and biggest problem. Greta’s world begins to tilt the moment she sees Elián dragged into the school in chains. The Prefecture’s insidious surveillance, its small punishments and rewards, can make no dent in Elián, who is not interested in dignity and tradition, and doesn’t even accept the right of the UN to keep hostages.

What will happen to Elián and Greta as their two nations inch closer to war?

What I Liked:

I think this might be a huge case of "it's not you, it's me". Or maybe it IS the book. I don't know. The ratings on Goodreads are very polarizing (at least, in my mutual friend group - but even outside of that group). To be honest, I wasn't really interested in this book. If the publisher hadn't sent an ARC, I wouldn't have read it. I don't make a habit of reading unsolicited review copies, but given the massive amount of flailing that people were/are doing over this book, I decided to give it a shot.

Read on.

What I Did Not Like:

I gave this book a shot. It failed. Epically. And to be honest, there is no venom or sting in my one-star rating. I just couldn't think of a single thing I liked. I wasn't overly upset over this one, or disappointed. It was so meh and blah, and I couldn't recommend it to anyone (if you hadn't heard of it before, keep walking).

I know some people liked the beginning but found the ending lacking. And some people loved the ending but found the beginning slow. For me, I found the entire book dry and boring, so there was no one part that I absolutely hated or absolutely loved. I will say, I had an easier time reading the beginning - the first one hundred pages. But keep in mind, this is largely due to the fact that I knew NOTHING about this book before reading it. So the first hundred pages were boring... but I still had hopes that maybe I was just tired, or it would pick up soon.

It never picked up. And I got even more tired, even as I got more awake (I had started this book on a car ride around 8:30 am, but picked it back up around 2:00 pm). This book was draining me, and not because it was so exciting or action-packed or emotionally investing. No, I was bored.

Maybe I never got into the world-building. This book is set waaaay into the future, in which the heir children of royalty are taken hostage, and killed when their parents go to war with another country or territory. It's just the way things are. This wasn't really interesting or intriguing to me. Greta, the protagonist, lives in constant fear of her mother declaring war on someone else.When Elián is brought to the hostage group as a hostage, there is a shift in... something. He is all about escaping and breaking the way things are. He refuses to be a "good hostage".

Something about that alone seems cliche. Of course one day a boy shows up and changes everything. While it's totally true that one action can change the course of history... I just wasn't feeling it, in this book. Basically, I wasn't feeling this book?

I almost DNF after about 150 pages. I skim-read a HUGE CHUNK of the book, at least 100 pages after the 150 already read. I just didn't read it with as much care. I didn't want to DNF, because I still held onto the hope that it would get better. It didn't. I can't say anything about the plot specifically because that would be a call for spoilers but... I didn't really get into the action. Once the hostage situation "disappeared", the book lost its appeal. Not that it had any appeal to begin with (FOR ME).

The romance also killed things a bit for me. There is a love triangle going on in this book. That's bad enough, right? But the thing is, the author has you thinking that the protagonist is going to fall for one person, and spends a lot of page time showing these two making moon eyes at each other or whatever. But then the author introduces another leg in the romance (hence, the triangle), and switches gears. So it's like we're deceived into falling for Greta + person A, because then Greta turns to person B. I honestly didn't care if the person Greta loved was person A or person B. But I don't like falling for one ship, only for the other ship to be the successful one. If that makes sense?

Because the thing is, in this book, I couldn't care less who she loved. Both of the love interests were dull, cliche, and uninteresting. One of them was supposed to be the "bad boy", the new guy, the one who changes the thinking of the protagonist. The other love interest was the steady rock, the best friend since forever. Two very cliche roles, and two very boring romances. Neither was swoony, and I picked the wrong one, the one I liked more. The fact that I had to "pick" is BS (I like it when there is one love interest and one only!).

Are you getting a lot of meh vibes from me? That's because this book was solid meh. I almost wish I could be like, I HATED THIS BOOK UUUUGGGHHH!, because then there would be some passion in this review.

The ending is so confusing! Heck, the whole book is, after a point. Kind of abrupt too, and weird. It gets so weird. I don't know if the author really fleshed out the plot. Like, THREE things happen in this book. Not a lot going on! Which, well, supports the meh feeling. MEH.

And to make matters worse, this book appears to be a standalone. I feel like a sequel would maybe lift my rating a notch, only because at least I could tell myself that some of my confusion and questions could be addressed in another book. Nope nope nope. Not according to this PW rights report!

Would I Recommend It:

I really can't recommend this book. It's dystopia, but it's just weird. And not a good weird. A boring weird that doesn't get better. A boring weird that needs a lot of development on all fronts. I don't even know what I read. I skim-read about half of it, which is extremely rare! If you were already excited about this one, then you should definitely read it. If not, skip!

Rating:

1 star. Really, this rating is reflecting the amount of things I actually liked about this book (i.e. nothing). It's not that I hated everything. It's just that I didn't like anything. If that makes sense. It's all in the subtleties! Or something.
Profile Image for R.J..
Author 16 books1,453 followers
May 10, 2015
Brilliant, haunting and unforgettable. I've read this story in three different drafts now, twice in manuscript and now in ARC form, and it gets more extraordinary every time. The worldbuilding is original and thorough, the characters diverse and full of humanity (including some that aren't, technically, human) and the story keeps ratcheting up the tension with a perfect balance between humor and horror. You will never look at goats, or certain pieces of farm equipment, without either laughing or wincing again.

Oh, and the back cover copy is true, but almost entirely misleading. Don't assume anything based on it, is all I'm going to say.

***

Old version: I've read this manuscript twice so far. It was stunning and brilliant the first time; the second time it was, almost impossibly, even more so.

I hope a smart editor snaps it up and finds magical ways to make it even better, but on the other hand if that happens my head may explode.
Profile Image for Dear Faye.
492 reviews2,134 followers
July 13, 2015
This is the film Lucy on crack.

With a lot of world politics.

And F/F interracial romance that was sweet, amazing, and heartbreaking.

HOLY COW!
Profile Image for The Candid Cover (Olivia & Lori).
1,220 reviews1,615 followers
February 21, 2020
Full Review on The Candid Cover

The Scorpion Rules is a dystopian novel not to be missed. It has got an original concept, a strong female character and really beautiful writing. I recommend that everyone read this book because it is definitely one of the most unique and thought provoking books of this year!

I love the concept of the Scorpion Rules! Basically, all the royal children are taken as hostages. If war begins in their country, the hostages will die. This concept is so original and described so well that the reader can easily visualize the setting and story. Sometimes in a novel, if a concept is so detailed, the book doesn’t live up to my expectations, but Erin Bow pulled off The Scorpion Rules really well! I loved every detail about this wonderfully crafted book.

Greta is a really superb main character for The Scorpion Rules. She knows that she could die at any minute if her parents break the peace, yet she is completely accepting of this fact. Greta doesn’t whine or complain about how difficult her life is, which I really enjoyed about her. She is strong and can take care of herself. I definitely recommend this to fans of books with strong female characters.

One of my favourite things about The Scorpion Rules is Erin Bow’s beautiful writing. Everything is so descriptive and I can easily picture myself in the book. Every character is so well developed, even the side characters! Because of the way it is written, even the dark elements in the book are extraordinary. I actually attended a writing workshop with Erin Bow a few years ago and I can see how her process has really come to life in The Scorpion Rules. I’m sure that everyone will enjoy this jewel of a book!

The Scorpion Rules has a very unique concept, a brave and strong main character, and is written extremely well. This is a must-read for every dystopian fan out there! I can’t wait for this book to come out so I that can fangirl with everyone!
Profile Image for TheBookSmugglers.
669 reviews1,908 followers
November 19, 2015
Ana’s Take:

Once upon a time (or, four hundred years ago), the world literally went to shit. Climatic catastrophes, wars and plagues raged until an artificial intelligence named Talis got fed up and took charge of the world’s weapons system and turned them against the warring nations. But the threat of annihilation wasn’t enough – the AI did not want to keep destroying entire cities after all – so Talis made it more complicated. Talis made it personal.

He (it?) created the Children of Peace. Each monarch, president or world leader had to send their sons and daughters to a Precepture where they will be kept as hostages. If those leaders ever declare war on another leader, their children get killed. To make it even more personal, it’s not like the children are brought up completely separated from their parents – Talis makes sure that they all go back home from time to time to create intimate bonds in order to make the decision harder.

Make it personal. Indeed.

Greta is a crown princess who has known the price of peace. All her life, she has known that her death might be just around the corner. But just like the other Children of Peace, she has been conditioned taught how to restrain her feelings and she knows that if the day comes she will walk to the Grey Room with her head held high, in quiet dignity.

Until one of her best friends, Sidney, gets killed when his country declares war against another. And she knows she is next because she understands the politics back home. All of a sudden, Greta knows terror. Things only get worse when Sidney’s replacement, a boy named Elián is brought in, in chains, raging and defiant. Unlike the other Children, Elián was not brought up controlled and observed. He has not been conditioned to accept the rules. He also doesn’t know that if he breaks them, the entire group gets punished.

The boy is the final catalyst to unleash Greta’s prodigious mind and to open her eyes to see what was before her the entire time. And once that happens, there is no stopping her.

I will start, perhaps unfairly, with the reason why I almost did not read The Scorpion Rules. The blurb is so incredibly misleading – if not necessarily untrue to the story – making The Scorpion Rules sound like yet another one of those run-of-the-mill het romance dystopian YA that I am so tired of. It was only my faith in Erin Bow’s storytelling skills that made me pick it up and holy crap, was this good.

There is nothing typical about this story.

The romance? Lesbian – possibly bi, maybe even poly in the future. When Greta finally opens her eyes, it also opens her heart to the friendships she never embraced and the love who was staring her in the face all this time. Her roommate and eventual lover Princess Xie is equal parts badass and dignified coolness.

The dystopian? Convincing, horrific. The “make it personal” moto is one of the most terrifying premises – because it works. Because it puts people in impossible situations of actual, lived terror. The Children of Peace? MY HEART. Erin Bow’s aforementioned skills shine here once more. This author has broken my heart more time than I can count with her books – for she tends to pull no punches, leave no rock unturned. Her female characters are incredibly well-written with a well-balanced mixture of vulnerability, compassion and badassery. Greta is no different: starting the book as an ice princess in an act of self-defence, the more the story progresses, the more that cool exterior melts leaving her heart open to be broken. Her eyes open to understand the numerous ways that her life has been controlled, curtailed and conditioned. The book starts and she knows nothing at all about these kids who have lived with her for years. The book progresses and those stories unfold.

And then, we have the Unexpected Subplot. Beneath the dystopian story, the immediate conflict surrounding Greta and Elián’s impeding death, we have the contextualised history of Artificial Intelligence. Talis is a monster. But somehow he is also a somewhat sympathetic and funny monster. And then we have the ending: the mindblowing decision that Greta makes is perhaps one of the most surprising twists I have ever had the pleasure (if one can refer to a monumentally dark and profoundly disturbing change, a “pleasure”) of reading.

Finally, it would be remiss of me if I didn’t mention the goats. The goats are hilarious. The Scorpion Rules is definitely a Notable Read of 2015.

Thea’s Take:

What can I say here other than the fact that I COMPLETELY agree with Ana’s assessment of the book?

The Scorpion Rules is a dystopian YA novel… but it’s not a dystopian YA novel that you’ve read before. It certainly sounds like it is, from the book description:

In a future world where civilization has collapsed and been reborn, where environmental catastrophe has led to war, and war has led to the United Nations allowing a supercomputer Artificial Intelligence named Talis to make suggestions, a new world order is born. Talis, awake and fully in control, starts bombing cities at random to get humanity’s attention. Talis then lays down the hard line and tells everyone that if you want to rule, give me your children so I can hold them hostage and keep you in line. The Children of Peace are taken from their parents and taught by Talis’s automatons and proctors, and are given valuable lessons that will help them rule and lead. Should a nation or state go to war, the children of those warring factions will be killed with little fanfare and no recourse.

For centuries, this process has worked (more or less).

Greta, a princess and future ruler of her land, lives in constant fear that she will be killed, knowing how close to war her country is with its American neighbor to the south. But then a new boy enters the Precepture (hostage from a newly formed and declared nation), and changes everything she knew about herself and the way she views the world.

It sounds like a classic “Girl (PRINCESS, no less) meets Special New Boy” and then “Girl falls in love with Special New Boy” and then “Girl and Boy CHANGE THE DYSTOPIAN INJUSTICE OF THEIR WORLD”, right? I am SO over that. I think the whole world might be over that.

But The Scorpion Rules?

It is NOT that book.

This is a clinic on subversion, because that’s what Erin Bow does best–she takes the basic expectations attributed to dystopian YA fiction and romance, and then twists them until they are no longer recognizable. And I mean that in the best possible way.

The villain, for example, is no one-note evil monolith–Talis is charismatic and glib, and the “scriptures” or book that the Children of Peace quote from isn’t what you think. The romance isn’t between Greta and Elián, but between Greta and Xie (but it’s not the focus or thrust of this book in any case). And really, the journey here is about Greta’s awakening to her own power and the broadening of her worldview–for she has always known the Precepts School, and has been there since she was five years old. Greta’s voice is powerful in itself; her characterization and her careful concern and methodical thought process is a delight (and heartbreak) to read.

I am loathe to say anything else about the awakenings that happen and the choices that are made for fear of spoilers; suffice it to say that the twists are awesome and shocking, and the effect of the story is profound.

This is another beautiful, thought-provoking book from Erin Bow, and one I absolutely recommend. The Scorpion Rules will absolutely be on my list of notable reads of 2015.

Profile Image for Andrea.
373 reviews124 followers
June 25, 2017
“Let me tell you a story. Once upon a time, humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.”

This book should have worked. It had an exceptionally clever premise, diverse characters, and a unique romance. Unfortunately, I found it to be pretty boring.

The Scorpion Rules takes place in a world governed by an artificial intelligence known as Talis. In order to keep the peace between countries and make sure war is never declared, world leaders exchange their own children as hostages. Should a country declare war on another their children will be murdered. The “Children of Peace” are raised in isolated schools known as Preceptures.

Sounds interesting, right? Sadly, for me, this is an example of a great idea but poor execution. There was a lot of info-dumps, and unfortunately, it didn’t make a lot of sense to me. And while I appreciate the diversity in the characters I felt like there were too many names and they all sort of blurred together for me, there was nothing unique about any of them. Greta (the MC) was supposed to be a sort of leader to all the other Children of Peace, but I seriously could not tell the difference between her and all the other children.

But what bothered me the most though was the writing. It was especially awkward and flat. And the pacing. I learned way more about farming and goats than I needed to. To me there was just nothing really exciting this story. Seriously, the best part of this book was the prologue.

**ARC provided in exchange for an honest review**
Profile Image for Helen 2.0.
467 reviews1,259 followers
May 25, 2017
In one word: AWESOME.

Even though the Scorpion Rules is set in a post-apocalyptic world where children of world leaders are held hostage to prevent war, the book is super entertaining. And, although Talis is a genocidal merciless AI overlord, it's really hard to hate a villain who makes sex jokes, references Star Wars, pats heavily armed enemy soldiers on the heads like puppies, and has strangely paternal feelings towards the heroine. I'm not saying I forgive Talis for murdering millions of people, I'm just saying it's all... relative.

I know the whole "robots take over the world" story is not particularly original, but Erin Bow puts her own unique twist with the Children of Peace and inventive characters. The Scorpion Rules is definitely a book all its own.

About the characters, can I be in love with every single one? Not all are morally clean, especially AIs like Talis and the Abbott, but they all have human aspects, and like I said it's relative. Greta's romantic entanglements caught me by surprise, but in a good way. He author didn't play into us readers' expectations.
Weirdly enough, with Greta and Talis, I kind of... ship them? Not in a romantic way necessarily, I just want their relationship to grow stronger and go where it may; really I just want more. I'm desperate for a sequel.
Profile Image for Sherwood Smith.
Author 152 books37.5k followers
Read
July 20, 2015
Another entry in the "teens in jeopardy" subgenre, this one stood out for me because the super government actually made sense in how it came about.

It's lethally simple: world leaders have to surrender their kids, and if they declare war, the kids are killed by the AI who now controls the weapons platforms of the world.

I think this book would be upsetting for younger readers, as the kids in jeopardy are really in danger of their lives. Including little ones. You find that out in the first few pages. At least, it would have punched me right in the heart as a kid reader, and not in a good way.

Teens into the whole Hunger Games subgenre will get right on board, especially as the voice is so distinctive. Greta, the first person narrator, is a princess who has been living with a cluster of hostages most of her life. She gets to go home every so often so she isn't forgotten. The complexity of her relationship with her mother, the queen, is conveyed through a teenage emotional filter, as are Greta's other relationships.

There is even a love triangle, but this one is, like the world building and setup, completely different from others, a bravura job. Bow's narrator is very observant of the details of human interaction, and the AIs are set up in such a way as to be very believable. And interesting.

Central is the AI named Talis who rules the world. He was once human four centuries ago, which explains the manic persona, fiercely intelligent but with emotions all over the map. And a strongly implied underlying anger. Sane or disconnected from what keeps us human? Does that much power keep anyone sane? Lots of very good questions raised, and no pat answers.

Greta versus Talis is a fascinating conflict, and I didn't see the end coming. Interesting stopping place, with enough resolution not to be a cliff-hanger, but with threads that promise a significant upping of the game. I inhaled it in one day. I wish the second one was out right now!
Profile Image for Justine.
1,224 reviews340 followers
July 20, 2016
You cannot control a man if you take everything from him. You must leave him something to lose.

For four hundred years an AI named Talis has kept the peace on Earth by requiring all the world's leaders to surrender their children to be educated and raised in an isolated Precepture run by AIs. These Children of Peace are blood hostages, and their lives are immediately forfeit should any of their respective countries engage in war with the other. Talis maintains tight control over this system, and since he has complete control over all orbital weapons, he certainly has the firepower to back it up...and he has done so in the past, to great effect.

But when a new hostage arrives who doesn't want to just accept the way things are it marks the start of a chain of events at the Precepture, and for the Children of Peace who live there, life will never be the same.

This is a book that by it's summary seems to indicate it will be an interesting, if typical dystopian YA tale. It's not.

This book takes the expected tropes and subverts them all, populating the story with a range of diverse and fully realized characters, from the innocent and worldly Children of Peace to the monstrous and snarky Talis.

The story itself is also multi-layered, bringing an exploration of the richness of the human experience, the bonds of love and friendship being front and centre. But instead of relying on a typical romantic relationship or a love triangle, there is instead a much more realistic exploration of the different kinds of love that people feel for one another and how we draw strength from that.

All my life I’d lived under the threat of death—mine, my friends’. I’d been a pawn in a scheme about the greater good, and I had kept myself asleep in order to survive. I was awake now. And I had found . . . love, all around me. Love where I had never expected it to be.

The Scorpion Rules is heartbreaking, powerful, and ultimately redemptive. I'm putting it on my favourites shelf for 2016.
Profile Image for Nastassja.
424 reviews1,220 followers
March 28, 2016
DNF at about 70%

The problem with The Scorpion Rules is that this book has no plot. And that it is boring and the characters are flat. And the story is a mess. I honestly struggled through this book, I believed that one more page and real story will begin. I read 50% of the book and nothing happened. When things started to move at least, they were incredibly slow and still, it felt like nothing was happening. And by this time I was done and did not care about the story or characters at all. And the sad part is that I had very high hopes for this book.

This is a dystopia. I'd even say that it is some kind of high fantasy and sci fi blend? The premise was very intriguing. I was waiting for some version of Terminator with teenagers fighting evil (awesomely sarcastic) AI (artificial intelligence). Well, AI wasn't that evil, but it was the best character in this book and... goats. Goats play a big role in the story. The rest of the herd characters were insignificant.

MC Greta is a nanny ninny. She was like a dying swan the whole book. At first, I tried to to be in her shoes. She is a hostage and very likely will die soon. But nope, nothing trembled withing my cold heart. Bad me. I would rather prefer this Greta girl executed sooner than later.

My heart leapt. I felt dizzy, blind, sick with joy. I was not going to die; only Sidney was. I was not going to die. Only Sidney.

Very compassionate indeed.

And then there's this love triangle between Greta and her two potential loves: a boy Elian and a girl Da-Xia. And it wasn't even strange, no, it just appeared out of thin air and I did not feel any connection between Greta and her loves.

Again, I could have explained. Da-Xia and I were not lovers, we were— What were we? How could I be worried about this when the apple press was being made ready? How could it be that I could still conjure a quickening in my blood when I thought of her kiss? We were not— We were . . . I did not know.

It was strange. We were from opposing nations that were at the brink of war. We were days away from dying for that war. And yet I would have done almost anything for Elián.

He loves me, she loves me not, blah, blah, blah - boring. Let's better talk about goats. Like I said, they are very important. If you'll ask me why, I won't be able to answer. But our Greta loves goats and she is the queen of this book, so of goats we will talk.
Fall is the breeding season for goats in any case, but to bring all the nannies into estrus in the right week, we hedge our bets. Ampoules of goat pheromones come in our yearly supply shuttle, with our clothing, salt, medicine, paper, and the handful of other things we cannot make for ourselves. The pheromones are of two kinds. We snap open the thin glass tubes of Essence of Billy Goat and apply it to a buck rag, which can be simply rubbed around the face of the nannies. This is a smelly business, but is nevertheless the better half of the job. The other half, a synthetic hormone, must be applied, shall we say, internally. From the other end. Put it this way: hormone day is not the highlight of our year.

The billy goat came down like a wolf on the fold. Elián dashed sideways to the melon patch to cut him off. He scooped up a green watermelon that must have weighed as much as a cannon ball, hoisted it over his head, and, with a wild rebel yell, threw it at Bonnie Prince Charlie. The projectile had deadly accuracy and speeds approaching escape velocity. It hit Charlie between the eyes. The goat made a rude blart, paused to consider the matter, and then keeled over.

Seriously, about 30% percents of this book is about goats.

The Scorpion rules is not all that bad. This book raises some serious issues like climate shift and wars for water.

He droned about how the land wars of the early twentieth century had shifted to oil wars and then water wars. He droned about what came next. About how rapidly rising sea levels, shifting weather patterns, and the collapse of petroleum-dependent agriculture had led to famine, disease, and displacement, to huge populations on the move.
These in turn had led to the War Storms—dozens of intensely fought regional wars that had crashed across the world in waves, engulfing first one set of countries and then another, and then circling back. War, plague, hunger. The global population fell by half. Then two thirds. Then three quarters.

And now, I can properly introduce you to Talis - AI and the best character of this book.
Once upon a time, said the Utterances, the humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.
The UN’s best AI, a Class Two named Talis, had been charged with finding ways to predict—and, where possible, prevent or end—the conflicts that were rapidly tearing up the planet.
That Talis’s strategy would be to put himself in charge was not something his human colleagues had foreseen. But that was exactly what he had done, neatly taking control of the networked weapons systems, most notably the ones in orbit.Right! he is said to have said. Everybody, out of the pool!
Then he started blowing up cities until everyone was stunned enough to scramble out and stand, dripping.

Utterance is like a book of rules and suggestions Talis created and everyone should follow them or... well, you can imagine what else from the rules.
Sorry about the constant crushing surveillance and all that, says Talis.

I’m talking handguns, crossbows, said the Utterances. Hell, bring back broadswords—those were cool. If you want blood, then I want it all over your hands.

Talis’s first rule of war: make it personal.

Resistance is futile

Yeah, said the Utterances. In my considered opinion, riots are bad for morale.

I didn’t actually mean for the hostage thing to create a whole bunch of hereditary monarchies, saith the Utterances. But, you know, whatever. Murdering princesses. I guess I can work with that.

And there were a lot of this little subtle remarks. Of course, they are better understood while reading with context. But there goes another question: Does this book worse reading? IMO - No. This book is a mess of everything. All the things that are ok as separate, were absolutely disastrous together in this story. The writing was chaotic, jumping from one thing to another. For me, it was hard to read, I was constantly concentrating on what's going on or rather what is not going on, and if I lost one link of what was happening, I had to come back and read it again. And all this considering, I repeat, nothing significant or exciting was happening. Just the chaotic writing style. Plainly said - this book was bad. No interesting plot - check, no intriguing characters - check (ecxept of goats and AI), no pace - check, no action - check. Honestly, after reading 70% of the book, I have no idea what this story is about. What is the purpose of MCs? Was it about world saving or about your-own-skin-saving?

The verdict: the most disappointing read of 2015.

Profile Image for Eilonwy.
851 reviews214 followers
May 19, 2016
A few centuries in the future, the world has suffered terrible catastrophe due to global warming: The poles melted, fresh water became scarce, and war after war was fought. Then an AI called Talis gained control, and a sort of peace. But the peace is twisted, dependent on the willingness of world leaders to sacrifice a beloved child in exchange for the right to declare war.

They’re more willing than you’d like, if you were one of those children.

Her Royal Highness, Greta Gustafson Stuart, Duchess of Halifax and Crown Princess of the Pan Polar Confederacy, 16 years old, is a Hostage Child, held at a Precepture in Saskatchewan from the age of five until she turns eighteen. The children are taught lessons by robots and kept busy planting and harvesting vegetables and caring for goats. The days and the years turn with the seasons.

And always, always, death hangs over their heads.

As you might guess, this is a pretty brutal future world. And it’s a pretty brutal book, with none of the reality of living in such a world sugar-coated or softened. I had a hard time getting through this one because of that, and had to take a few days off from it. But I am glad I persevered to the end.

The story opens when one Child from Greta’s age cohort is sacrificed and replaced with another from a newly-formed alliance: Elian Palnik, a boy who doesn’t want to be at the Precepture and who is determined to test the limits of his captivity. It’s not like Greta wasn’t aware of the harshness of their circumstances, but seeing the repercussions of Elian’s actions drives it home fresh and hard.

Then Greta’s and Elian’s countries declare war upon one another.

And I can’t tell you anything else for risk of spoilers.

This is a crazy brilliant sneaky genius intense book which really got under my skin, as I felt like I was living in it the entire time I was reading it (hence my need for a break when things got a little TOO intense). It seems like it’s setting up to be a romance and possibly a love triangle, as Greta finds herself attracted to Elian and, maybe, to another character I won’t reveal. But it’s really a book about power and how it’s wielded. It’s also a terrifically sad book about loss, the kind you can’t control, and, weirdly enough, the kind you can. The writing is beautiful and subtle, and cut me to pieces. As you might guess, there are no happy endings possible. But the ending is brave and unusual. I saw it coming, didn’t want to go there, fought it the whole time I was away from the book … and then found that the author took me through it so skillfully and insightfully that it seemed almost okay. Still awful, but also okay. Okay enough that I might even manage to read the sequel.

So why am I giving this four stars? Well, it’s an awfully heartbreaking and violent story; it gave me unsettled dreams, which is probably to its credit, but I also kind of wish I could unsee some of it. And there’s maybe too much about goats where there could have been more about people -- most of Greta’s cohorts at the Precepture are just vague outlines with not much personality, which is a shame. Also, since we actually meet Talis, I eventually found myself wondering, “Just exactly how did this abrasive jerk become Ruler of the World?” Maybe that gets explained in the next book.

But wow, if you want to read something different, and you’re feeling emotionally strong, give this book a shot.
Profile Image for E.K. Johnston.
Author 21 books2,549 followers
April 8, 2015
This book, I tell you. I mean, I have read a lot of books (as you do), and this one is one of my favourites. Possibly my absolute favourite. It is that good.

The world building is astonishing. Erin Bow has created not only an entirely believable future, but also an entirely believable set of characters to fill it. You can *smell* the goats when you read it. And the politics! My heart, the politics.

I can't even tell you about the most amazing part, though, because that wouldn't be fair to you. You will just have to wait until September and then we can all yell about our feelings on Twitter.
Profile Image for Allison.
489 reviews194 followers
March 26, 2016
Non-formulaic, diverse, vaguely dystopian YA novel!!!!!!!!! \o/ I didn't even mind the love triangle because it wasn't really a love triangle at all!!! GOD, THIS WAS GREAT. /god/

Ok, the first thing I need to say is that I LOVED Greta, the narrator and protagonist. The main reason for this is that she. was. dutiful. and. responsible. The entire novel is about her willingness to die for and be useful to the ~tyrannical system~ because she knows it generally works to keep the peace. This is so much preferable to any number of other privileged (yeah, Greta is a hostage, but she's a princess and future world leader, so yes she's PRIVILEGED) YA protagonists who push the envelope because instalove or because they don't want to put their brilliant tactical minds to work for their nation and would for no good reason rather study music, even though they obviously LOVE TACTICS AND PROBLEM-SOLVING (*cough cough pointed barb at a series I hated*).

The other characters are also fantastic, especially Xie, Elias, and Talis (they're the most well-fleshed out besides Greta herself), but also the Abbot (a surprisingly complex secondary AI character), and the other Children of Peace. I won't spoil anything here, because Bow really pulls the rug out from under the back-of-book summary (*cackle*), but I particularly loved Xie.

I also really enjoyed the world-building and the grittiness that permeated the entire novel. After the first fifty pages or so I knew this wouldn't be a neatly packaged YA narrative with a smooth ending. Thank God. Wow, and there were like....adults in active roles in here too! Amazing! (Sorry, I read a ton of mediocre YA this year)

And someone, please, make me stop reading and watching things about AI this year. xoxo
Profile Image for Lindsay Cummings.
Author 15 books5,072 followers
Read
November 10, 2015
Wow. Super unique and I can't believe Greta ACTUALLY did it. Bravo, to the author, for taking the leap and making her main character make a choice that was tough and completely life-altering. Greta is brave.
Profile Image for mj.
93 reviews104 followers
March 2, 2018
I don't think I have the words to describe just how much I adored this book.

Profile Image for Lindsay.
1,312 reviews251 followers
August 18, 2016
First, civilization was on the brink of collapse due to global warfare over the scant resources of a post-climate change world. And then Talis took over. Talis is a powerful AI with control over the world's supply of orbital super-weapons which he only had to use a dozen times or so before people got the point. In the new world there are rules, and one of those rules is that war is personal. So if you're going to lead a country you need to have children. Children that will be taken hostage and killed if your country goes to war, whether your country started the fight or not.

The story starts 400 years after Talis took over. We follow Greta, the daughter of the ruler of the Pan-Polar region, a super power in the new world, but one on the brink of war across several fronts. She lives in on of Talis's Preceptures, essentially prison camps/schools run by AI robots where the children live under brutal surveillance conditions and the threat of torture and corporal punishment. The children here will eventually be rulers of their own nations, but right now they're all hostages for good behavior. Even so, children are still taken away to be killed when they're countries go to war. The post-climate change world has plenty of desperate people because resources are scarce, and the choice of going to war and having your child executed or having your country die of thirst is a simple one.

Even given all this, the constant threat of death and the brutal conditions she lives under, Greta is a classicist trained in Greek and Roman history and in many ways an innocent. A huge motivating factor in her life is that when she will go to the Grey Room she will go with dignity. But then someone new arrives, Elián, the grandson of the General in charge of a country that's about to go to war with Greta's and calm dignity in the face of sacrifice is the last thing on his mind. He fights and rebels, invoking Sparticus when he can and reminding everyone in the Precepture that they're slaves. Of course he's punished, and brutally so, but it completely shatters Greta's calm.

I don't want to go into what happens more than the setup because it's brilliant, and shocking in places.

All of this sounds like a Hunger Games-like dystopia doesn't it? It's not that simple. There's reasons for everything here, and while Talis's setup is brutal and inhuman, it's undoubtedly saving far more lives than it costs. Once the story gets moving, Talis's mandate that war be personal is underlined, because conflict comes to the Precepture and all the involved parties get involved. Greta, ever the sacrifice, is called in much more horrible ways than she was prepared for.

I can't wait for the next book.
Profile Image for Aleksandra.
1,497 reviews
October 26, 2017
The actual rating is 4,5 stars.

Okay, all you need to know about The Scorpion Rules is that you need to read it. I wish I could write beautiful all-encompassing review about this mind-blowing book but I don't have the necessary skills. Please read the book, it's unique, gripping and thought-provoking.
The fact that I can't write reviews hasn't stopped me yet, so...

The Scorpion Rules is a wild mix of politicals schemes and plottings, thriller and sci-fi. Future Earth is ruled by all-powerful AI with Tony Stark-ish sense of humor and dubious moral compass. Bunch of kids who caught in the whole power games and who are essential parts of the said games. Protagonist Greta's character development is hands down A+. I need to point out that romantic subplot is the most sensible thing I've read recently. No relationship drama. None. No pettiness or jealousy. Because come on, there's death and life situations, no time to fight among your own people. And it's subplot, the main story is all about survival, politics and hard choices.
I already mentioned AI. His name is Talis and he's my new favorite villain. Talis is an amazing character, I wanted to punch him 90 % of his "screen time", however I couldn't help but agree with his views and methods on how to rule the planet. They are ruthless but they serve its purpose, they are effective... Obviously, my morals and ethical principles haven't survived the book uncorrupted and I don't think they've recovered yet.

Why not 5 stars? - Because I didn't care that much about the characters. I liked them lots, they were amazing well-developped kids, but there wasn't any emotional connections. In case one of them died, I was like "okay how will it affect the plot? what will happen next?". Thus 4-4,5 stars.

All in all, The Scorpion Rules is mind-blowing political thriller set in sci-fi future and you definitely should read the book if these things are your cup of tea. ( If they are not, read anyway, you might change your mind about the genre).

P.S. The bisexual protagonist and other lgbt characters who are awesome and who aren't reduced to their sexuality. Diverse cast. Realistic portrayl of relationships and struggles and choices the characters are making and the consequences of these choices. Beautiful and hilarious writing. Please read the book.
P.P.S. No pressure obviously. a little bit of pressure...? ;)
Profile Image for Susana.
994 reviews260 followers
September 22, 2015


Arc provided by Margaret K. McElderry Books through Netgalley

"

Look, reading the first pages, I thought for sure that this was going to be a winner: the concept! For crying out loud!
I haven't read a book with an addictive concept like this one in ages.

Unfortunately, the execution feels as if it followed a god damn list: insert this... insert that... no soul whatsoever.

Here's the thing, I am all about diversity in books. And at first glance, this book seemed to have nailed it perfectly.

We have characters from different parts of the globe. One Asian character is in fact one of the main characters ( and part of a pointless love triangle), and were you to ask me which of them all, I cared for the most, my choice would have to be Xie, because Greta annoyed the hell out of me.

We have GLBT relationships, although I didn't find any depth whatsoever in them.
In fact, I didn't find any depth in any of the characters or relationships between them.
There wasn't any character development.

Greta is supposed to be this great leader, someone that all the other kids follow and listen to, and I honestly don't see what's so special about her. She's as interesting as yesterday's bread.

What brings us to the actual story...
Imagine a bunch of kids on a farm, and they have to manage said farm if they want to eat... that implies farming, and animal husbandry, namely goats.
I think I had read about seventy percent of this, when I decided to count how many goat references there were... I counted one hundred and twenty five.

Do not sell a book as a Hunger Games "wannabe", with flat characters and more than one hundred and twenty five references to goats.
This was boring and draining to read, and the only reason I didn't DNF it is because I've become too stubborn to do it.
As for the Evil guy, the master mind behind the reality these kids are living, the AI who controls the world?
o_O
Sorry, but it was filled with too many plot holes.
I can honestly say that I won't be continuing with this series.
Profile Image for Giselle.
1,067 reviews909 followers
March 23, 2016
Greta lives in Canada and is the princess of the Pan Polar Confederacy reign. All the countries in the world have their children who are holed up on a farm where they wait to die by the hand of the Keepers. Eventually Greta's whole world is turned upside down when an American boy Elain comes in and is tortured. The aftermath created when an AI called Talis created by the U.N. takes over the world. Bombing cities and even entire countries if needed. Suddenly she realizes there are more sinister things at work than just her regular day to day life.

The greatest part about this book is the world building. It was seriously one of the most interesting takes on how our future could be. I loved how it wasn't all dumped on to the reader like most dystopian novels. It's done in mere trickles. Considering how slow paced the novel was, finding bits and pieces of how and why the world came to be was surprisingly effective. There are also quirky weird parts like the Children of Peace who end up busy mating goats.. It made me laugh though.

As for the characters, I couldn't get a good read on most of them. They didn't reveal too much of their back story and I had trouble remembering them all even the secondary characters. I did like how there was an LGBT relationship. That's rare to find in dystopian novels. I only wished there were more development for each of them. And the plot was super simple but with the type of world building it had, it made sense not to make it over complicated.

Overall, if you like a different take on a dystopian novel, pick this one up just for the world building. You won't be disappointed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,559 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.