What do you think?
Rate this book
384 pages, Hardcover
First published September 22, 2015
A sonic boom.The summary of the book makes it sound pretty great. The reality about this book is that it's about a bunch of kids living their life in a nonsensical and supremely confusion faux-dystopian world who have been sheltered their entire life with the knowledge that they are "hostages." A new stranger comes into their midst to be rebellious and get punished by the hostages' keepers and to tell them that THINGS ARE NOT WHAT THEY SEEM. Gasp. Shock. Horror. Awe. Such a thing has never happened before in dystopian fiction.
It crashed into us like a slap to the ear. The stuck goat shouted. From the trees all around, loose apples pattered down. Grego bolted for the edge of the grove, leaving Atta alone with the ladder.
We all wanted to go with him, of course, but—
“Wait! The goat!” I called.
My classmates stopped and turned and looked at me. On their faces, varying degrees of annoyance, resignation, and respect sorted themselves into agreement, obedience. This is what it is like, in my experience, to speak as royalty. Even to other royalty.
“Our duty is with the goat,” I said.
But the fun had gone out of things. A few shocks, distributed at random; the knowledge that we were watched; the fact that we had been raised better (or if not better, at least differently)—these overcame us. The Children of Peace could not easily be silly, and our silliness fell apart.Yeah. That's what happens for the majority of the book! Exciting! There are 7 of them and I can hardly tell them apart. There is no character to any of them. No life. No soul.
The evening found us bruised and quiet, spread out in groups or pairs on the spattered grass, eating our former ammunition—chunks of watermelon and muskmelon warmed by the bronze sun. Even this was unlike us—unstructured, unrationed eating, outdoors. But we could not waste so much food. We scattered up and down the garden terraces; we lay in the goat-cropped grass and were happy.
It started when the ice caps melted. We saw it coming, and we were braced for the long catastrophe, but in the end it came unbelievably fast. All of a sudden there were whole populations under water.
The Cumberland Alliance emerged from a regional shakeup among the losing parties. Like many nations it was defined by water: in this case, the drainage of the Ohio River basin. It stretched south to Nashville and north to Cleveland, with a capital at Indianapolis and a military-industrial center at Pittsburgh.I don't even care what happens. I don't even care that I can flip to the end to find out the conclusion. Bye.
“Did you know, the man who invented the atomic bomb once said that keeping peace through deterrence was like keeping two scorpions in one bottle? You can picture that, right? They know they can't sting without getting stung. They can't kill without getting killed. And you'd think that would stop them." He gave the book another boot, and it flipped closed with a snick. "But it doesn't." He looked up and his eyes were the color of Cherenkov radiation, the color of an orbital weapon. "You've got a bit of nerve, little scorpion. All I did was invent the bottle.”
"Thus my heart began to turn against the only truth I'd ever known."
"Borders strained, checkpoints broke, and of course people started shooting, because that what passes for problem-solving among humans. See, guys, this is why you can't have nice things."
"You sound exactly like a textbook, do you know that?" he said. "It's amazing."
"All of a sudden there were whole populations under water. Which meant that whole populations moved. Borders strained, checkpoints broke, and of course people started shooting, because that’s what passes for problem-solving among humans. See, guys, this is why you can’t have nice things.
Sit down, kiddies. Let me tell you a story. Once upon a time, humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.So begins Erin Bow’s new young adult dystopian novel, The Scorpion Rules, with Talis, the snarky but cold-hearted artificial intelligence overlord of the earth, explaining how humanity got itself into its current bind. The earth’s ice caps melted, which led to massive population migrations and water and food shortages, and from there to global series of regional wars, disease and famine that led to a seventy-five percent reduction in earth’s population.
Well, I say “my job.” I sort of took it upon myself. Expanded my portfolio a bit. I guess that surprised people. I don’t know how it surprised people — I mean, if they’d been paying the slightest bit of attention they’d have known that AIs have this built-in tendency to take over the world. Did we learn nothing from The Terminator, people?
In Halifax I am duchess and crown princess. When I come here the prairie sky opens up over me. I fold the crown princess away like linens into lavender, and I am Greta again… The last time I was in Halifax, my mother did not mention a war. But she did not invite me to privy council either, as she usually does. And on the last day of my visit she herself brushed the thousand strokes through my hair. She wasn’t crying, but she was….The characters in The Scorpion Rules are unique and diverse; hostages are gathered from all over the globe. Moreover, they are unique and fully realized, including the secondary characters. Thandi from Africa is touchy and prideful, but is protective of the group and the best person at judging how far the rules can be pushed. Talis, who controls the world, seemed at first improbably sarcastic and taunting for an artificial intelligence, but as the story unfolds and Talis’ background and history are disclosed, these qualities and other human-like characteristics in Talis are fully explained. Bow does an excellent job of fitting the pieces of the story together in a way that makes sense.
Surely she would warn me. Surely she would not let me be surprised.
“Let me tell you a story. Once upon a time, humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.”
The problem with The Scorpion Rules is that this book has no plot. And that it is boring and the characters are flat. And the story is a mess. I honestly struggled through this book, I believed that one more page and real story will begin. I read 50% of the book and nothing happened. When things started to move at least, they were incredibly slow and still, it felt like nothing was happening. And by this time I was done and did not care about the story or characters at all. And the sad part is that I had very high hopes for this book.
This is a dystopia. I'd even say that it is some kind of high fantasy and sci fi blend? The premise was very intriguing. I was waiting for some version of Terminator with teenagers fighting evil (awesomely sarcastic) AI (artificial intelligence). Well, AI wasn't that evil, but it was the best character in this book and... goats. Goats play a big role in the story. The rest of the herd characters were insignificant.
MC Greta is a nanny ninny. She was like a dying swan the whole book. At first, I tried to to be in her shoes. She is a hostage and very likely will die soon. But nope, nothing trembled withing my cold heart. Bad me. I would rather prefer this Greta girl executed sooner than later.
My heart leapt. I felt dizzy, blind, sick with joy. I was not going to die; only Sidney was. I was not going to die. Only Sidney.
And then there's this love triangle between Greta and her two potential loves: a boy Elian and a girl Da-Xia. And it wasn't even strange, no, it just appeared out of thin air and I did not feel any connection between Greta and her loves.
Again, I could have explained. Da-Xia and I were not lovers, we were— What were we? How could I be worried about this when the apple press was being made ready? How could it be that I could still conjure a quickening in my blood when I thought of her kiss? We were not— We were . . . I did not know.
It was strange. We were from opposing nations that were at the brink of war. We were days away from dying for that war. And yet I would have done almost anything for Elián.
Fall is the breeding season for goats in any case, but to bring all the nannies into estrus in the right week, we hedge our bets. Ampoules of goat pheromones come in our yearly supply shuttle, with our clothing, salt, medicine, paper, and the handful of other things we cannot make for ourselves. The pheromones are of two kinds. We snap open the thin glass tubes of Essence of Billy Goat and apply it to a buck rag, which can be simply rubbed around the face of the nannies. This is a smelly business, but is nevertheless the better half of the job. The other half, a synthetic hormone, must be applied, shall we say, internally. From the other end. Put it this way: hormone day is not the highlight of our year.
The billy goat came down like a wolf on the fold. Elián dashed sideways to the melon patch to cut him off. He scooped up a green watermelon that must have weighed as much as a cannon ball, hoisted it over his head, and, with a wild rebel yell, threw it at Bonnie Prince Charlie. The projectile had deadly accuracy and speeds approaching escape velocity. It hit Charlie between the eyes. The goat made a rude blart, paused to consider the matter, and then keeled over.
The Scorpion rules is not all that bad. This book raises some serious issues like climate shift and wars for water.
He droned about how the land wars of the early twentieth century had shifted to oil wars and then water wars. He droned about what came next. About how rapidly rising sea levels, shifting weather patterns, and the collapse of petroleum-dependent agriculture had led to famine, disease, and displacement, to huge populations on the move.
These in turn had led to the War Storms—dozens of intensely fought regional wars that had crashed across the world in waves, engulfing first one set of countries and then another, and then circling back. War, plague, hunger. The global population fell by half. Then two thirds. Then three quarters.
Once upon a time, said the Utterances, the humans were killing each other so fast that total extinction was looking possible, and it was my job to stop them.
The UN’s best AI, a Class Two named Talis, had been charged with finding ways to predict—and, where possible, prevent or end—the conflicts that were rapidly tearing up the planet.
That Talis’s strategy would be to put himself in charge was not something his human colleagues had foreseen. But that was exactly what he had done, neatly taking control of the networked weapons systems, most notably the ones in orbit.Right! he is said to have said. Everybody, out of the pool!
Then he started blowing up cities until everyone was stunned enough to scramble out and stand, dripping.
Sorry about the constant crushing surveillance and all that, says Talis.
I’m talking handguns, crossbows, said the Utterances. Hell, bring back broadswords—those were cool. If you want blood, then I want it all over your hands.
Talis’s first rule of war: make it personal.
Resistance is futile
Yeah, said the Utterances. In my considered opinion, riots are bad for morale.
I didn’t actually mean for the hostage thing to create a whole bunch of hereditary monarchies, saith the Utterances. But, you know, whatever. Murdering princesses. I guess I can work with that.
The verdict: the most disappointing read of 2015.
A few centuries in the future, the world has suffered terrible catastrophe due to global warming: The poles melted, fresh water became scarce, and war after war was fought. Then an AI called Talis gained control, and a sort of peace. But the peace is twisted, dependent on the willingness of world leaders to sacrifice a beloved child in exchange for the right to declare war.
They’re more willing than you’d like, if you were one of those children.
Her Royal Highness, Greta Gustafson Stuart, Duchess of Halifax and Crown Princess of the Pan Polar Confederacy, 16 years old, is a Hostage Child, held at a Precepture in Saskatchewan from the age of five until she turns eighteen. The children are taught lessons by robots and kept busy planting and harvesting vegetables and caring for goats. The days and the years turn with the seasons.
And always, always, death hangs over their heads.