Tae, 12 Jan 2024I guess this is gonna be my phone for the next 3 years. But I am thinking of buying the Ch... moreX6 Pro is the better choice. Wait for price drop
motop, 12 Jan 2024Also this is winter If they re run these antutu geekbench in hot you will see throttling Bruh, indoor climate control is a thing you know. And gsmarena has mentioned before they strive to test phones in similar situations i.e. same room temperature.
Aierlan, 13 Jan 2024Yeah, I think this would be a reasonable approach. Many of the gsmarena team expressed their d... moreExcellent critique, gsmarena is quick to shout lack of innovation
But doesn't introduce thermometers for heat tracking in performance test
Doesn't improve their rating system
Heck there is a whole new generation of technical reviews from golden reviewer and geekerwan and gsmarena has not adopted a single new technique
And like you mention dxomark has some interesting display testing
But maybe when or if the gsmarena team reads this they just laugh at us or interpret these critiques as we saying they have to copy everything or start over
Just take a few bits from here.. something as small as thermometer results.. you know baby steps
motop, 12 Jan 2024You made wrong How can consider these Antutu and geekbench results when you test in winter ve... moreYou probably got a fake one
jiyen235, 12 Jan 2024just Geekbench and Antutu? What about the GPU? Ain't no way only CPU and storage inflated... moreDidn't you read the reviews, it says Xiaomi limits the number of tests they can run
PureOS, 12 Jan 2024Just 4.0 rating?! This super machine they compare with A54, which in their own words was most ... moreThey need Samsung sponsor that why Samsung product get different treatments. Personally I never find A54 that good last year, but I understand why is popular. Considering similiar price range(do mind this my region price) Poco F5, Vivo v29, oppo Reno10, Xiaomi 13T, I find these device more appealing last year devices.
And I haven't considered GSMArena rating for long time, just read their review on each part, comparing with other reviewers, then make personal conclusions. Their rating system is a joke. And like you said need overhaul and be more transparent how their rating worked.
PureOS, 12 Jan 2024Just 4.0 rating?! This super machine they compare with A54, which in their own words was most ... moreI think Poco X5 Pro camera quality is better than X6 Pro.
PureOS, 12 Jan 2024Just 4.0 rating?! This super machine they compare with A54, which in their own words was most ... morePOCO F5 has better SoC, better camera and best looking ... and overall cheaper
Zuzuz, 12 Jan 2024I wouldn't do that. I would just give points for every category: screen, battery, camera ... moreYeah, I think this would be a reasonable approach. Many of the gsmarena team expressed their disappointment at the lack of innovation in phones but if they look at their own review format there has been little change/innovation at all apart from the battery rating in such a long time. I think their camera tests could be improved a lot for example, although I do appreciate that they provide original photos which is very good. Also all reviews will be subjective to some extent but for reasonable consistency of scoring I think there does need to be some weighting across different categories. Part of the issue is that they never seem to have launched an article explaining how their overall score works. Is it just an impression score or is their a system? My guess is that it's just a score given on overall impression as they haven't explained it to their audience. Personally, for this reason I don't pay much attention to the overall score or even the pros and cons at the end. Better just read through the whole reviews and form your own opinion
There is no comment on bloatware advertisements etc in hyperos in the review
just Geekbench and Antutu? What about the GPU? Ain't no way only CPU and storage inflated that Antutu score that high. The GPU change from Mali 610 to 615 must've meant something at least.
So hyperOS bubble burst now.
Nothing surprising 🤯
Djellal, 12 Jan 2024Ikr just say it loud GSMArena When they said only ip54 in cons i barely knew how to react lma... moreNot to mention that A25 with exynos 1280 have the same price as this device in 12/512gb configuration.
PureOS, 12 Jan 2024Just 4.0 rating?! This super machine they compare with A54, which in their own words was most ... moreIkr just say it loud GSMArena
When they said only ip54 in cons i barely knew how to react lmao i was like ???? Ip54 is SO GREAT to already begin with
This phone was 259$ on AliExpress yesterday, you wanna have 4k on uw ip68 premium matte finish ? It's a bit ridiculous
And yeah the 4.0 rating seems odd to me. Hope they'll do something about their rating
Pumpino, 12 Jan 2024"there's no old-school combined interface for quick settings and notifications"... moreI hate the ios notification system, as do a lot of iPhone users. Give me a combined notification/setting screen
"there's no old-school combined interface for quick settings and notifications"
Does that mean that the option to use the old style quick settings has been removed? If that's the case, it's a deal-breaker for me. I'm not using that iOS inspired design. It's also laughable that Xiaomi has removed the text labels for the toggles.
Why would Xiaomi remove the option to have horizontal scrolling recent apps in Poco models, but leave it in other models? One wonders what the thinking is, or even if there is thinking.
GSMA - no mention of colour accuracy of the display? These reviews seem to be declining in quality.
Vivo Iqoo 9 and 9 pro are solid alternatives too.
ashrobb, 12 Jan 2024I hope you guys re-run these benchmark tests in a week or so. Having no GPU benchmarks for bot... moreAlso this is winter
If they re run these antutu geekbench in hot you will see throttling
Why is video capped at 30fps with such a powerful SoC?This is 2024, what is this Poco??
Also why is screen brightness lower compared to regular X6?
Last but not least, to no ones surprise, yet another Xiaomi(poco)device with built in ads you have to manually disable....
Tip us
1.7m 126k
RSS
EV
Merch
Log in I forgot my password Sign up