Top critical review
3.0 out of 5 starsPredictable and novel as well
Reviewed in Canada on May 20, 2023
Within the first few pages you are exposed to the predictable plot of the neophyte hiker teaming with the wise experienced protagonist. All of the typical tension and consequences that we have read before. The twosome walk into the depths of the John Muir trail at the same time try to dive deep into to the meaning of life. This is ambitious. What we get is mostly armchair philosophy and surface spirituality. "What if this was the last day of your life?". But as a detailed narrative of the experience of hiking the JMT the book shines. As an armchair long distance hiker myself I was immersed in the trail and the descriptions painted a picture that allowed a taste of the experience. I felt in a small way I was there with them even though I cringed at times at some of their choices. The 3D map drawings showing their progress along the trail with the corresponding elevation gain and loss found me wanting to adjust my own pack for the chapter ahead. It's worth reading as an adventurous romp on the trail.